No offense meant, but you yourself admitted to not playing much during set 4 Peralisc.
I played lots during set 4 too, but then played little by the end of it (when i was about to grind the last 3 EX packs, the falkow ones, i simply lost my mood). And i just said what i remember, didn't try to contradict what others remembered playing against.
There were a lot of EM and Primrose-return and they were in the top weekly grinders and the top RP.
How many primrose-return players are there currently? Just curious.
And usually when there is someone playing a lot one file and winning tons, the guys with the counters show up as if someone paid them to camp and counter that file. It has counters, but none that instantly end the game for the primrose player, so a mega-counter is the only way people might counter a file enough to make it played less?