justtmpuser wrote:A bunch of 'reviews'
Sounds like you're primarily looking at the files themselves rather than what's in the battles (which is really ironic when you yourself say that the contest is about the battles and not the files), saying individual files are 'disqualified' for using certain units or SS. And I don't see the point in 'reviewing' every single replay, especially when the majority of your reviews seem to be insulting the files and players that have posted calling them unoriginal and boring.
I'm wondering who's alt you are because you certianly seem to have a strong bunch of opinions for such a relatively new poster.
also in regards to what you said about my replay
https://alteil-login.gamepotusa.com/aud ... 8667796c30
I'm typing reviews as I watch battles, so it might change in future, but this is without doubt one of THE most uninteresting games ever. Mage Soldiers? Check. All types of return? Tidal. Check. Return. Check. Wrath. Check. Same SS as 90% of players? Lets see. Distier. Check. Rasam. Check. Chamail + 2nd SK SS combo? Check. You win all right. First place for the most unoriginal deck. Go find a skyscraper. You know what to do.
That's getting a little unneccesarily offensive there. I know it's difficult to claim as everyone got the cards at the same time, but I was one of the first to really work with the new Mage Soldiers, and try to find something fun and consistent in Folrart. I tested a lot of ideas and I was the one who made the MS guide. Calling it unoriginal is a bit uncalled for when I didn't reference anyone elses file while I was making it except for the Chamail 2nd shrine SS combo, and as far as I've noticed, I'm the only one who's tried a more survival route with MS using Ascarat rather than an offensive rush file. I enjoy Mage soldiers cause the're an interesting file, and while they're powerful they're not top meta so I'm not sure what your complaint with them is.
You can have your opinion certainly, but that doesn't mean you can insist to everyone else your opinion is right and everyone who uses effective cards are scum for wanting to win. This contest isn't about avoiding commonly used cards, or it would've said so at the beginning. We get the idea you didn't like most of these replays, but there are better ways to express it than insults and telling people to kill themselves for playing a game.